Student Studying Math

Saxon Math Review: An Honest Look After Using It With Our Kids

By Nick & Amanda | Updated September 2026

This post contains affiliate links. If you purchase through our links we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. We only recommend products we’ve genuinely researched and believe in.

Saxon Math is one of the most recognized names in homeschool mathematics — and one of the most polarizing. Families either love it passionately or find it completely wrong for their child. Very few people are neutral about Saxon.

We used Saxon Math with some of our kids — not all of them. That experience taught us more about who Saxon works for than any curriculum guide ever could. Here’s our honest assessment.

Saxon Math — Quick Reference:

FeatureDetails
Grade levelsKindergarten through Calculus
ApproachIncremental — sequential — continuous review
Lesson time45-60 minutes per day
Parent involvementMedium — teaching script included for elementary
Secular or ChristianSecular — no religious content
Placement testAvailable at saxonmath.com
Approximate cost$60-120 per level
Best forSequential learners — structured — no gaps
AmazonShop Saxon Math on Amazon →
ChristianbookShop Saxon at Christianbook →

What is Saxon Math?

Saxon Math is a comprehensive mathematics curriculum published by Houghton Mifflin Harcourt — originally developed by John Saxon in the 1980s as a response to what he saw as the failure of traditional math textbooks to produce genuine mathematical competence.

Saxon’s approach is built on two foundational principles:

Incremental development: New concepts are introduced in small, carefully sequenced steps — one new idea at a time, building systematically on what has been taught before. No concept is introduced before its prerequisite has been mastered.

Continuous review: Previously learned concepts are continuously reviewed throughout the curriculum. Every Saxon lesson includes practice of new material alongside review of previously taught concepts. Nothing is taught once and then dropped — everything is revisited repeatedly over months and years.

These two principles — incremental introduction and continuous review — define the Saxon approach and distinguish it from virtually every other math curriculum on the market.


The Saxon Math Lineup — Complete Overview

Saxon publishes math curriculum from kindergarten through calculus:

Elementary:

  • Saxon Math K
  • Saxon Math 1
  • Saxon Math 2
  • Saxon Math 3

Upper Elementary/Middle School:

  • Saxon Math 5/4 — for strong 4th graders or average 5th graders
  • Saxon Math 6/5 — for strong 5th graders or average 6th graders
  • Saxon Math 7/6 — for strong 6th graders or average 7th graders
  • Saxon Math 8/7 — pre-algebra for strong 7th or average 8th graders

High School:

  • Saxon Algebra 1
  • Saxon Algebra 2
  • Saxon Geometry
  • Saxon Advanced Mathematics
  • Saxon Calculus

The dual numbering system — 5/4, 6/5, 7/6, 8/7 — reflects Saxon’s philosophy that students should work at their actual mathematical level rather than their grade level. A 5th grader working in Saxon 5/4 is working at an accelerated pace. A 6th grader in Saxon 5/4 is working at grade level.


The Saxon Lesson Structure

Every Saxon lesson follows a consistent structure that students quickly internalize:

Warm-Up — 5-10 minutes: Mental math practice, fact practice, and problem-solving warm-ups. Builds automaticity and mathematical fluency through daily practice.

New Concept — 10-15 minutes: Introduction of the new concept — explained clearly with worked examples. Elementary levels include a script for the teaching parent. Upper levels include explanatory text the student reads independently.

Lesson Practice — 10 minutes: Problems specifically practicing the new concept just introduced. Relatively few problems — enough to check initial understanding without overwhelming.

Mixed Practice — 20-30 minutes: The heart of Saxon — 25-30 problems covering a wide range of previously taught concepts alongside the new material. This is where the continuous review happens. Every problem set in Saxon reviews everything taught previously — nothing disappears.

Total lesson time: approximately 45-60 minutes for most levels.


Our Experience With Saxon Math

We used Saxon Math with some of our kids — and it was the right choice for those children. The sequential structure was exactly what they needed — the careful step-by-step progression that left no gaps, the continuous review that ensured nothing was forgotten, the predictable lesson structure that provided consistency.

For those children Saxon produced exactly what it promises — genuine mathematical competence built on a solid foundation. The strong sequential structure meant that when they reached algebra they had every prerequisite firmly in place. The continuous review meant they retained what they had learned rather than forgetting it over summer breaks.

For our other children we chose differently — because Saxon is not the right fit for every learner. The lesson length can be challenging for children who fatigue easily. The repetitive structure can feel tedious for children who grasp concepts quickly. And the approach to geometry — integrated rather than a standalone course — frustrates some families.

That mixed experience is the most honest and useful thing we can share: Saxon works extraordinarily well for the right child and not well at all for the wrong child. Knowing which category your child falls into before you invest is worth more than any curriculum review.


Who Saxon Math Works Best For

This is the most important question in any Saxon Math review — and the one most curriculum guides answer too vaguely.

Saxon works best for:

Sequential learners: Children who need concepts introduced in small carefully ordered steps — who get confused when too much is presented at once — thrive with Saxon’s incremental approach. If your child does best with one new idea at a time and needs to master it before moving on Saxon is designed for them.

Children who benefit from extensive review: Some children forget previously learned material if they don’t see it regularly. Saxon’s continuous review ensures that nothing learned is lost. For children with weak mathematical memory Saxon’s review structure is genuinely valuable.

Children who need predictable structure: The consistent lesson structure of Saxon — warm-up, new concept, lesson practice, mixed practice — provides a predictable routine that benefits children who do better with consistency. Anxious children and children with ADHD often appreciate knowing exactly what to expect from every math lesson.

Families who want a complete sequential program: Saxon provides a complete mathematical sequence from kindergarten through calculus with no gaps. A student who completes the Saxon sequence has covered everything needed for college-level mathematics. For families who want one program that takes them all the way through Saxon delivers.

Children preparing for standardized testing: Saxon’s systematic coverage and continuous review produces strong standardized test scores. The breadth of review in every lesson means Saxon students retain mathematical knowledge in a way that benefits test performance.


Who Might Struggle With Saxon

Fast learners who grasp concepts quickly: Saxon’s incremental approach introduces concepts slowly and reviews them extensively. A child who grasps a new concept immediately may find the pace frustratingly slow and the review tedious. For gifted math students Art of Problem Solving is a more appropriate challenge.

Read our complete review: Art of Problem Solving Review →

Children who struggle with sitting still: A complete Saxon lesson takes 45-60 minutes — one of the longer math lessons in the homeschool curriculum market. Children with ADHD or high movement needs may struggle to sustain focus for a full Saxon lesson. Consider breaking lessons into two shorter sessions or switching to a shorter-lesson curriculum.

Visual and kinesthetic learners: Saxon is primarily a pencil-and-paper curriculum. It has limited hands-on components and minimal visual representation of concepts. Children who need to see and touch math before they understand it may find Saxon’s abstract approach difficult. Math-U-See is a better fit for these learners.

Families who want standalone geometry: Saxon integrates geometry concepts throughout the curriculum rather than offering a standalone geometry course. Some families — particularly those following a traditional high school math sequence — prefer a dedicated geometry course. This is one of the most common frustrations among high school Saxon users.

Children who find repetition demotivating: The continuous review that makes Saxon effective for some children is genuinely tedious for others. A child who learned a concept thoroughly three months ago and is still reviewing it daily may become frustrated and disengaged. Know your child before committing.


Saxon Math — Level by Level Recommendations

Elementary — Saxon K through 3: Saxon’s elementary levels are gentle, thorough, and script-based — making them highly accessible for new homeschool parents. The meeting component — a daily calendar and counting activity — provides a structured opening routine that young children enjoy.

Best for: New homeschool families, children who benefit from structured routine, children who need careful step-by-step introduction to math concepts.

Get Saxon Math 1 on Amazon → | Christianbook →
Get Saxon Math 2 on Amazon → | Christianbook →
Get Saxon Math 3 on Amazon → | Christianbook →

Upper Elementary — Saxon 5/4 through 8/7: These are Saxon’s strongest levels — the incremental approach and continuous review produce genuine mathematical competence in the critical upper elementary and pre-algebra years. The transition from the scripted elementary levels to the more independent upper levels requires adjustment but most students make it successfully.

Best for: Sequential learners in grades 4-8, children preparing for algebra, families who want thorough coverage of pre-algebra concepts.

Get Saxon Math 5/4 on Amazon → | Christianbook →
Get Saxon Math 6/5 on Amazon → | Christianbook →
Get Saxon Math 7/6 on Amazon → | Christianbook →
Get Saxon Math 8/7 on Amazon → | Christianbook →

High School — Saxon Algebra 1 through Calculus: Saxon’s high school sequence is rigorous and comprehensive — producing college-ready mathematical competence for students who complete it. The Teacher DVD sets — video instruction for every lesson by DIVE or Art Reed — are invaluable for high school levels and essential for parents who feel less confident with upper-level math.

Best for: Sequential learners preparing for college, students who struggle with abstract mathematical reasoning and need careful step-by-step development.

Get Saxon Algebra 1 on Amazon → | Christianbook →
Get Saxon Algebra 2 on Amazon → | Christianbook →
Get Saxon Advanced Mathematics on Amazon → | Christianbook →


The Teacher DVD Sets — An Essential Add-On

One of Saxon’s most valuable accessories — particularly for middle and high school levels — is the Teacher DVD sets produced by third-party providers.

DIVE Math: CD/DVD-based video instruction for Saxon courses from 5/4 through Calculus. Dr. David Shormann provides clear, engaging instruction for every Saxon lesson. Invaluable for homeschool parents who feel less confident teaching upper-level math.

Art Reed DVDs: Another popular Saxon DVD option — Art Reed’s clear teaching style has helped thousands of homeschool students through Saxon’s upper levels.

Why they matter: The upper Saxon levels — particularly Algebra 2, Advanced Mathematics, and Calculus — are genuinely challenging to teach without a strong mathematics background. The Teacher DVDs allow students to receive instruction from a mathematics expert rather than relying entirely on the parent. For many families this is what makes Saxon viable through high school.

Get DIVE Saxon Math on Amazon → | Christianbook →


Saxon Math — Placement

Correct placement in Saxon is essential. Starting too high produces frustration and gaps. Starting too low produces boredom and wasted time.

Saxon’s placement recommendations: Saxon publishes placement tests at saxonmath.com — use these before purchasing any level. Don’t assume your child should be in the level that matches their grade — Saxon’s dual numbering reflects this explicitly.

General placement guidelines:

  • Strong 4th grader → Saxon 5/4
  • Average 5th grader → Saxon 5/4
  • Strong 5th grader → Saxon 6/5
  • Average 6th grader → Saxon 6/5
  • Strong 7th grader → Saxon 7/6 or 8/7
  • Average 8th grader → Saxon 8/7

When in doubt place one level lower rather than higher. The review in every lesson will quickly cover anything your child already knows — and gaps discovered mid-level are far more disruptive than an easy start.


Saxon vs Other Math Curricula

CurriculumApproachReview StructureLesson LengthBest For
SaxonIncremental, spiralContinuous — every lesson45-60 minSequential learners, thorough coverage
HorizonsSpiralRegular review30-40 minMost learners — engaging and colorful
Math-U-SeeMasteryPeriodic review20-30 minVisual/kinesthetic learners
SingaporeMastery, conceptualLimited review30-40 minConceptual learners
Teaching TextbooksSpiral, digitalRegular review30-45 minIndependent learners
Art of Problem SolvingChallenging, conceptualLimitedVariableMathematically gifted

Read our complete guide: How to Teach Math at Home
Read our complete Math-U-See review: Math-U-See Review →
Read our complete Teaching Textbooks review: Teaching Textbooks Review →
Read our complete Singapore Math review: Singapore Math Review →


The Cost of Saxon Math

Saxon is a mid-range to moderately expensive math curriculum:

LevelApproximate Cost
Elementary levels (K-3)$70-100 per level
Upper elementary (5/4-8/7)$80-120 per level
High school levels$90-130 per level
Teacher DVDs (upper levels)$40-80 additional

Cost-saving strategies:

  • Buy used — Saxon holds its value well and used sets are widely available on Facebook homeschool groups and Amazon Marketplace
  • The student workbooks and tests are consumable — but the teacher’s manuals are reusable for additional children
  • Teacher DVDs are optional at elementary levels — essential at high school levels

Frequently Asked Questions About Saxon Math

Is Saxon Math secular or Christian? Saxon Math is secular — the content is not faith-based. It is widely used by families of all backgrounds including Christian homeschool families.

Does Saxon Math work for struggling math students? It depends on why they’re struggling. If a student struggles because of gaps in foundational knowledge Saxon’s sequential approach can fill those gaps systematically. If a student struggles because of learning differences affecting math — dyscalculia, visual processing issues — a more hands-on approach like Math-U-See may be more effective.

Can I skip levels in Saxon? Not recommended. The incremental approach means each level builds directly on the previous one. Skipping levels creates gaps that compound over time. Use the placement test to find the right starting level rather than skipping.

How long does it take to complete a Saxon level? Most students complete one Saxon level per school year at 4-5 lessons per week. Some students take longer — particularly at the high school levels.

Is Saxon a good college prep curriculum? Yes — students who complete Saxon through Advanced Mathematics or Calculus are well-prepared for college-level mathematics. Many Saxon students score well on SAT and ACT math sections due to the curriculum’s comprehensive review structure.

Get Saxon Math on Amazon → | Christianbook →


Our Honest Assessment

Saxon Math is one of the most rigorously sequenced math curricula available — and for the right student it produces genuine mathematical competence that we’re genuinely grateful for.

The strong sequential structure is Saxon’s greatest strength. Every concept is carefully placed in sequence. Every prerequisite is in place before the next concept is introduced. Every previously learned concept is continuously reviewed. A student who works through Saxon carefully and consistently arrives at each new level fully prepared.

The honest caveats: Saxon is not for every learner. The lesson length is demanding. The repetitive review is tedious for children who learn quickly. The integrated rather than standalone geometry frustrates some high school families. And the upper levels genuinely require either strong parent math knowledge or Teacher DVDs to implement effectively.

We used it for the children it fit. We chose differently for the children it didn’t. That’s the most honest recommendation we can make — know your child, use the placement test, and give it a genuine trial before committing fully.

For sequential learners who need careful step-by-step instruction and extensive review Saxon Math is one of the best options available.

Shop Saxon Math on Amazon → | Christianbook →


Shop Saxon Math:

Head to our Curriculum Reviews page to browse all our honest curriculum reviews.

And head to our Start Here page for everything you need to homeschool with confidence.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *