Family Homeschool Morning

Heart of Dakota Review: An Honest Look at the Charlotte Mason-Inspired Open-and-Go Christian Curriculum

By Nick & Amanda | Updated September 2026

This post contains affiliate links. If you purchase through our links we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. We only recommend products we’ve genuinely researched and believe in.

New homeschool parents face a specific and overwhelming challenge — the desire to provide a rich, literature-based, Charlotte Mason-inspired education alongside the reality that they have no idea how to actually plan and implement one. Charlotte Mason’s philosophy is beautiful in theory and genuinely difficult to execute in practice without significant experience, planning expertise, and curriculum coordination skills that most new homeschoolers don’t yet have.

Heart of Dakota was built to solve exactly this problem — a Charlotte Mason-inspired literature-based curriculum that provides all the living books, narration, hands-on activities, and biblical integration that Charlotte Mason families want, in a completely open-and-go format that tells parents exactly what to do every single day without requiring extensive planning expertise.

After 13 years in the homeschool community we’ve heard Heart of Dakota discussed consistently — particularly among Charlotte Mason families who want the CM experience without the CM planning burden, and among new homeschool families who want a complete literature-based program that works from day one. We haven’t used it personally — and we’ll be upfront about that throughout this review.

Read our complete Charlotte Mason Homeschooling guide: Charlotte Mason Homeschooling — A Complete Guide →
Read our complete Trail Guide to Learning review for a contrasting literature-based unit study: Trail Guide to Learning Review →
Read our complete Sonlight review for a contrasting literature-based approach: Sonlight Review →


Heart of Dakota — Quick Reference:

FeatureDetails
AuthorCarrie Austin — elementary education master’s degree — 11 years classroom experience
PublisherHeart of Dakota Publishing — family-owned — over 20 years
Grade levelsPreschool through Grade 12 — complete PreK-12 sequence
ApproachCharlotte Mason-inspired — literature-based — open-and-go — Christian worldview
12 program guidesLittle Hands to Heaven through World History
Daily lesson formatTwo-page spread — completely open-and-go
Subjects coveredBible, history, science, language arts, geography, art, music — most subjects
NOT includedMath — requires separate math curriculum
PhonicsIncluded at early levels — some families add supplement
GrammarIncluded at most levels
SecularNo — explicitly Christian — Protestant worldview throughout
Screen-freeYes — no video components
Family-ownedYes — Carrie Austin and family
CommunityActive Heart of Dakota Facebook groups — very supportive
Cost per guide$85-175 per complete guide package
ChristianbookShop Heart of Dakota at Christianbook →
DirectShop at heartofdakota.com →

What is Heart of Dakota?

Heart of Dakota is a comprehensive Charlotte Mason-inspired Christian homeschool curriculum written by Carrie Austin — a former classroom teacher with a master’s degree in Educational Leadership who began developing the curriculum over 20 years ago when she couldn’t find a literature-based Christian program that met her family’s needs. The curriculum now serves families from preschool through Grade 12 across 12 complete program guides — each designed for approximately one year of study.

Heart of Dakota’s defining feature is its open-and-go daily lesson format. Each day’s lessons are laid out in a clear two-page spread — the left page listing morning basket activities, Bible study, and read-aloud time, the right page listing independent student work and afternoon activities. Parents open the guide and teach without any preparation, planning, or curriculum coordination. Everything is provided, scheduled, and ready.

The curriculum is literature-based in the Charlotte Mason tradition — using living books to teach history, science, geography, and language arts rather than textbooks and workbooks. The books are carefully selected for quality and historical accuracy — many are the same beloved titles that appear in Ambleside Online and other Charlotte Mason booklists. Hands-on projects, notebooking, narration, copywork, dictation, map work, and timeline activities bring the content to life in the CM tradition.

The biblical worldview is central rather than incidental — God’s Word appears in every day’s lesson at every grade level through Bible study, memory verses, character development content, and the Christian perspective woven throughout the history and science instruction.


The Heart of Dakota Philosophy — Charlotte Mason Made Accessible

Heart of Dakota’s educational philosophy sits at the intersection of Charlotte Mason’s natural education philosophy and the practical reality that most homeschool parents need more structure and planning support than pure Charlotte Mason approaches provide.

Charlotte Mason principles at the core:
Heart of Dakota draws on Charlotte Mason’s conviction that children deserve a generous education — rich in great literature, living ideas, nature study, and exposure to art and music — rather than a dry textbook-driven transmission of facts. Short lessons, narration, copywork, dictation, living books, and the conviction that children are capable of genuine intellectual engagement with real ideas all reflect CM’s influence throughout the curriculum.

Structure that Charlotte Mason purists don’t provide:
Where Heart of Dakota differs from pure Charlotte Mason approaches like Ambleside Online is in its structured daily plans. Pure CM families often plan their own schedules, select their own books from public domain lists, and develop their own narration prompts and activities. Heart of Dakota provides all of this — daily plans, book selections, activity ideas, narration prompts, and scheduling — removing the planning burden from parents who love CM philosophy but feel overwhelmed by CM implementation.

The open-and-go distinction:
Heart of Dakota’s community consistently distinguishes it from other CM-inspired programs by its genuine open-and-go nature. Unlike some curricula that claim to be open-and-go but still require significant daily preparation Heart of Dakota’s two-page daily spread is genuinely ready to use without advance work. The parent opens the guide — the day is planned. This distinction is one of the most consistently praised features in the Heart of Dakota community.

Biblical worldview as the foundation:
Every Heart of Dakota guide places God’s Word at the center of each day’s learning — not as a separate subject to be studied alongside academics but as the integrating framework that gives all other learning its meaning and purpose. This integration is explicit and consistent — parents who want secular academic content or who prefer to keep faith and academics separate will find Heart of Dakota’s pervasive biblical integration incompatible with their goals.


The 12 Heart of Dakota Guides — A Complete Overview

Heart of Dakota covers preschool through Grade 12 in 12 program guides — each typically covering one school year of study. The guides are designed for specific age ranges rather than strict grade levels — allowing some flexibility for families whose children’s skill levels don’t align neatly with their chronological grade.

Early Childhood — Preschool through Grade 1:

Little Hands to Heaven — Ages 2-5:
The foundational preschool guide — introducing young children to Bible, basic concepts, literature, and hands-on activities appropriate for the pre-reading stage. Little Hands to Heaven is designed for gentle exploratory learning that builds a love of books and a foundation of biblical knowledge before formal academics begin.

Little Hearts for His Glory — Ages 5-7:
The kindergarten guide — introducing phonics, beginning reading, and early academics alongside continued Bible, history, and science through the living books and hands-on activities approach. Little Hearts for His Glory is one of Heart of Dakota’s most beloved and most consistently praised guides — the blend of beginning academics with literature and hands-on learning resonates strongly with families making the transition from preschool to school-age learning.

Beyond Little Hearts for His Glory — Ages 7-9:
The first grade guide — continuing reading development, beginning phonics completion, and early elementary academics alongside history, science, and Bible in Heart of Dakota’s characteristic format. Many families describe Beyond as their first truly independent use of Heart of Dakota — students begin to take on more of their daily work independently.

Elementary — Grades 2-6:

Bigger Hearts for His Glory — Ages 8-10:
The second grade guide — deepening all subject areas with more sophisticated content as students become more fluent readers. Bigger introduces formal grammar instruction, more complex narration expectations, and history content that spans ancient through medieval periods.

Preparing Hearts for His Glory — Ages 9-11:
The third grade guide — often described as the guide where Heart of Dakota’s approach really blossoms. Students are reading independently, narrating confidently, and engaging with genuine historical content through living books. Many families consider Preparing Hearts the most satisfying and most smoothly implemented guide in the elementary sequence.

Bigger — History Through the Ages continuation:
Additional guides covering world history, American history, and more sophisticated academic content as students progress through the upper elementary years.

Middle School:

Missions to Modern Marvels and High School Guides:
Added beginning in 2009 Heart of Dakota’s middle school guides bridge elementary and high school content — increasing independence expectations, academic complexity, and writing demands while maintaining the literature-based open-and-go format. High school guides added in 2013 complete the K-12 sequence.


What’s Included in Heart of Dakota Guides

The Program Guide — the heart of HOD:
Each Heart of Dakota guide contains the complete daily lesson plans for the school year — laid out in the distinctive two-page daily spread that opens on the left to morning activities and on the right to afternoon/independent work. The guide specifies exactly which books to read, which pages to narrate, which activities to complete, and which projects to work on each day. The guide is reusable across multiple children — it’s not consumable.

Student Workbooks — consumable components:
Student-facing workbooks, notebooking pages, and activity pages are the consumable components of Heart of Dakota — each child needs their own set. The workbooks include narration pages, copywork, dictation, geography maps, timeline activities, and subject-specific practice pages.

Book Packages — purchased separately or bundled:
Heart of Dakota provides a complete reading list for each guide — the living books that form the spine of the curriculum’s history, science, and literature instruction. Books can be purchased individually, through Heart of Dakota’s bundled packages, or borrowed from the public library. Most Heart of Dakota books are widely available at public libraries — significantly reducing the cost for families who use their library aggressively.

Math — not included:
Heart of Dakota does not include mathematics — families must choose their own math curriculum to use alongside HOD. The community most commonly pairs Heart of Dakota with Singapore Math, Saxon Math, Teaching Textbooks, or Math-U-See. Heart of Dakota’s guides reference math concepts in the context of history and science but do not provide systematic math instruction.


The Two-Page Daily Spread — How Heart of Dakota Actually Works

Understanding Heart of Dakota’s daily lesson format is essential for evaluating whether it fits your family’s teaching style.

The left page — morning basket time:
The left page of each daily spread covers the shared family learning that happens together at the start of the day — Bible study and memory verses, read-aloud from the current history or science living book, character development discussion, poetry or hymn study, and morning basket activities that gather the whole family. This shared morning time reflects Charlotte Mason’s conviction that the richest learning happens when the family encounters great ideas together.

The right page — independent student work:
The right page covers the work the student completes more independently — copywork or dictation, narration writing, geography activities, timeline work, subject-specific practice, and afternoon projects. The balance between parent-led and student-independent work shifts as students progress through guides — younger students require more parent guidance while older students are increasingly independent.

The daily time investment:
Most Heart of Dakota families complete their daily lessons in 2-4 hours depending on grade level — shorter for younger students, longer for middle and high school. The curriculum is specifically designed for efficient implementation — the careful scheduling of short lessons across multiple subjects means the school day is substantive without being exhausting.


The Heart of Dakota Community — A Genuine Strength

One of Heart of Dakota’s most consistently praised features is its community — an active, supportive, and extensively documented online community that provides practical help, encouragement, and implementation advice that significantly reduces the learning curve for new HOD families.

The Heart of Dakota Facebook groups:
Multiple HOD Facebook groups — organized by guide level — provide a community of families working through the same curriculum simultaneously. Questions about implementation, book substitutions, scheduling adjustments, and activity modifications are answered quickly and generously by experienced HOD families. The HOD community’s willingness to share detailed implementation experience is one of the most practically valuable features of choosing Heart of Dakota.

Carrie Austin’s responsive customer service:
Heart of Dakota’s family-owned structure means customer questions frequently reach Carrie Austin herself — and the community consistently describes her customer service as genuine, responsive, and generous. This stands in sharp contrast to the customer service problems documented for Winter Promise and distinguishes Heart of Dakota as a publisher that genuinely cares about the families using its curriculum.

The HOD blog and website:
Heart of Dakota’s website includes extensive implementation guidance — blog posts covering placement, scheduling adjustments, multi-age teaching, special needs adaptations, and practical tips from Carrie Austin and the HOD community. Families new to HOD consistently describe the website’s resources as genuinely helpful in setting realistic expectations and implementing the curriculum effectively.


Heart of Dakota vs Other Charlotte Mason-Inspired Curricula

FeatureHeart of DakotaTrail Guide to LearningAmbleside OnlineSonlight
ApproachCM-inspired — open-and-goCM + Beechick + BloomPure Charlotte MasonLiterature-based history
Open-and-goYes — genuinelyYes — daily plans providedNo — significant planningYes — daily plans
Multi-ageLimited — guide-specificYes — designed for itYes — family schedulesLimited — Core ranges
Math includedNoNoNoNo — separate
Grammar includedYes — most levelsYes — language artsLimited — CM approachLimited
SecularNo — explicit ChristianChristian-friendlyBroadly accessibleChristian
CommunityVery active — Facebook groupsActiveVery active — forumsActive
Cost per year$85-175 guide + books$150-300 + booksFree — books cost$700-900 all-subjects
Best forCM families wanting structureCM + thinking skillsPure CM familiesRead-aloud families

The honest distinction:
Heart of Dakota is the most genuinely open-and-go of the Charlotte Mason-inspired options — providing daily plans, book selections, activity ideas, and all scheduling without requiring the significant planning expertise that pure CM approaches like Ambleside Online demand. Trail Guide to Learning similarly provides daily plans but integrates Bloom’s Taxonomy more explicitly. Sonlight covers more subjects in one package. Ambleside Online costs significantly less but requires significantly more parent planning. The right choice depends on how much planning support you need and how closely you want to follow pure Charlotte Mason vs. CM-inspired approaches.


The Cost of Heart of Dakota

ComponentApproximate Cost
Program guide per level — reusable$45-75
Student workbook pack per level — consumable$40-100 per child
Book package — varies by level$75-200 additional
Complete level — guide plus workbooks$85-175 without books
Complete level — guide plus workbooks plus books$160-375
Additional child consumables$40-100 per year

Cost-saving strategies:

Use the public library aggressively:
Most Heart of Dakota book selections are available at public libraries — families who use their library consistently can dramatically reduce the book cost. Heart of Dakota’s website provides complete book lists for each guide — check your library’s availability before purchasing any books.

Buy used guides:
The program guide is reusable and widely available used through Heart of Dakota Facebook groups, homeschool curriculum fairs, and eBay. Used guides at 40-60% off retail significantly reduce the upfront investment. Verify that the edition matches current student workbooks before purchasing used guides.

Reuse guides for multiple children:
The program guide serves all children who use that level — only student workbooks are consumable per child. Families with multiple children purchase the guide once and add only workbook packs for each additional child — making Heart of Dakota genuinely economical over time for larger families.

Christianbook discount:
Christianbook carries Heart of Dakota guides and workbook packs at meaningful discounts from retail — purchasing through Christianbook reduces the annual investment compared to purchasing directly.


Who Heart of Dakota Works Best For

Heart of Dakota is an excellent fit for:

✅ New homeschool families who want Charlotte Mason without the planning burden:
This is Heart of Dakota’s most natural and most consistently satisfied audience — families who are attracted to Charlotte Mason’s philosophy of living books, narration, and nature study but who feel overwhelmed by the planning expertise that pure CM approaches require. HOD provides the CM experience in a genuinely open-and-go format that works from day one without prior CM planning experience.

✅ Christian families who want biblical worldview fully integrated:
Heart of Dakota’s pervasive biblical integration — God’s Word in every day’s lesson at every grade level — appeals deeply to Christian families who want their children’s entire education understood within a biblical framework. The integration is genuine and comprehensive — not a Bible class added to secular academics but a curriculum built on the conviction that all knowledge is God’s knowledge.

✅ Families who are overwhelmed by curriculum coordination:
Heart of Dakota’s all-in-one format — covering Bible, history, science, language arts, geography, art, and music in one guide — significantly reduces the curriculum coordination that eclectic homeschooling requires. Families who have been juggling multiple separate curricula consistently describe the simplification of switching to Heart of Dakota as genuinely liberating.

✅ Families with young children who want gentle literature-based early education:
The early Heart of Dakota guides — Little Hands to Heaven and Little Hearts for His Glory — are among the most beloved early childhood Christian homeschool resources available. The gentle literature-rich approach, the emphasis on biblical foundation, and the hands-on activities appropriate for young learners make the early HOD guides particularly well-suited to the preschool and early elementary years.

✅ Families who value an active supportive community:
Heart of Dakota’s community — the Facebook groups, the website resources, and Carrie Austin’s personal responsiveness — is one of the most practically valuable features of choosing HOD. Families who benefit from community support, shared implementation experience, and accessible expert guidance will find the HOD community genuinely helpful throughout their HOD journey.


Who Might Want to Look Elsewhere

❌ Secular families:
Heart of Dakota’s biblical integration is pervasive and genuine — God’s Word appears every day at every grade level. Secular families will find the Christian content incompatible with their educational goals. Ambleside Online — which draws on many of the same Charlotte Mason principles with broadly accessible content — is a more appropriate choice for secular families who want a CM-inspired approach.

❌ Families who want pure Charlotte Mason:
Heart of Dakota is Charlotte Mason-inspired rather than purely Charlotte Mason. The structured daily plans, the specific activity directions, and the more directive format reflect a more structured approach than Charlotte Mason’s original philosophy prescribes. Families who specifically want the freedom and child-led flexibility of pure CM — who want to follow their child’s interests and develop their own narration prompts and activity ideas — may find HOD’s structured format more directive than their CM philosophy accommodates. Ambleside Online more closely follows pure CM principles.

❌ Families who want complete math instruction included:
Heart of Dakota does not include mathematics — families must source a separate math curriculum. Families who want one complete program that covers every subject including math should look at Sonlight’s All-Subjects Packages or Abeka’s complete curriculum instead.

❌ Families who prefer structured traditional academic instruction:
Heart of Dakota’s Charlotte Mason-inspired approach — short lessons, narration, living books, hands-on projects — is philosophically different from traditional textbook-and-workbook instruction. Families who specifically prefer structured traditional academic formats — daily tests, textbook chapters, comprehensive workbooks — will find HOD’s approach philosophically distant from their preferences. Abeka or BJU Press better serve these families.

❌ Families who need independent student work throughout:
Heart of Dakota requires daily parent involvement — particularly at the younger grade levels where the parent reads aloud, leads narration, and guides activities. Families who need their children to work entirely independently for significant portions of the school day will find Heart of Dakota’s parent-intensive morning basket approach challenging. The independence increases in the upper grades — but the early grades genuinely require daily parent presence and engagement.


Frequently Asked Questions About Heart of Dakota

How do I choose which Heart of Dakota guide to start with?
Heart of Dakota provides a detailed placement guide at heartofdakota.com — and using it is strongly recommended before purchasing. HOD’s guides are organized by age and skill level rather than strict grade level — students may appropriately begin a guide that is below or above their chronological grade level depending on their reading ability, prior academic experience, and overall maturity. Contacting Heart of Dakota directly with placement questions is also an option — Carrie Austin and her team are consistently responsive to placement questions from prospective families.

Can I use Heart of Dakota with multiple children at different ages simultaneously?
Yes — with some planning. Heart of Dakota’s guides are designed for specific age ranges rather than entire families — families with children spanning multiple age ranges typically use different guides for different groups of children rather than one guide for everyone. Some families pair children close in age in the same guide while using a different guide for older or younger siblings. The HOD community provides extensive practical guidance on multi-level implementation — the Facebook groups are the most practical resource for families navigating this question.

Is Heart of Dakota accredited?
No — Heart of Dakota is not accredited as a school or curriculum program. Most states don’t require accredited curriculum for homeschooling — but families who need accredited transcripts for college admission or other purposes should look at Abeka Academy’s accredited option or BJU Press Distance Learning instead. Heart of Dakota does provide guidance on documenting student work for transcript purposes.

What math curriculum works best alongside Heart of Dakota?
The Heart of Dakota community most commonly pairs HOD with Singapore Math — which HOD itself often recommends — alongside Saxon Math, Teaching Textbooks, and Math-U-See. The choice should be based on your child’s learning style and your family’s math teaching preferences rather than HOD compatibility — all major math programs integrate comfortably with Heart of Dakota’s flexible scheduling.

Does Heart of Dakota cover enough language arts?
Heart of Dakota covers language arts across most guides — including phonics instruction in the early guides, copywork and dictation throughout, narration practice at every level, and grammar instruction beginning in the elementary guides. Many families find HOD’s language arts coverage comprehensive. Some families supplement with dedicated grammar or writing programs — particularly at the middle and high school levels where more intensive writing instruction may be desired. IEW is a commonly used supplement alongside HOD for families who want more systematic writing instruction.

Shop Heart of Dakota at Christianbook →
Shop Heart of Dakota at heartofdakota.com →


Our Honest Assessment

Heart of Dakota fills a genuinely valuable position in the Charlotte Mason-inspired curriculum market — providing the living books, narration, hands-on activities, nature study, and biblical integration that Charlotte Mason families want in a completely open-and-go format that works from day one without requiring extensive CM planning experience.

The community’s experience with Heart of Dakota is consistently warm — families who choose HOD and whose educational philosophy aligns with its Charlotte Mason-inspired Christian worldview approach consistently describe it as one of the most satisfying curriculum experiences of their homeschool journey. The genuinely open-and-go daily plans, the carefully selected living books, the active supportive community, and Carrie Austin’s personal responsiveness all reflect a curriculum publisher that genuinely cares about the families it serves.

The honest caveats are real: Heart of Dakota does not include math — a separate math curriculum is required. The explicitly Christian worldview makes it inappropriate for secular families. The daily parent involvement requirement — particularly at younger grade levels — is genuine and significant. And pure CM families may find HOD’s structured format more directive than their philosophy accommodates.

For Christian families who want Charlotte Mason’s philosophy without Charlotte Mason’s planning burden — who want living books, narration, and biblical integration in a completely open-and-go format — Heart of Dakota is one of the most carefully designed and most consistently beloved Charlotte Mason-inspired curricula available.

Shop Heart of Dakota at Christianbook →
Shop Heart of Dakota at heartofdakota.com →


Head to our Curriculum Reviews page to browse all our honest curriculum reviews.

And head to our Start Here page for everything you need to homeschool with confidence.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *